I do not know if you knew, but Spn won all the categories they were nominated except the last. Here are the prices we've won (16 of 27 categories from 2007-2008):

2007:
Hottest-time (for sam-Madison)
Best momemnt-trigger (when the YED is dead)
-Best Dream Sequence (What Is and What Should Never Be)
heartbreaking-sacrifice (the deal)
Worst-enemy (the YED)
-Best fight (Sat prickles Gordon)
Moment brother to brother argument (discussion at the beginning of Hunted)


2008:
-Men in suit (the boys in Red Sky at Morning)
-Funniest moment (Mystery Spot)
-Best Special Effect
Best first-time hook-up (Sam-Bela. ... ask not how we won)
Best reunion-lover (Lisa Dean)
Appearance-Favorit return (Henricksen, the trickser, Ghostfacers etc. ..)
-Best (worst) ugly (Lilith)
-Best cliffhanger (Dean in hell)
Best-brothers moment


2009:
-Favorite Newcomer (Castiel)
-Best fight (Sat prickles Dean, When the Levee Breaks)
-Best friend forever (Sam / Dean)
Best-Finnally! It's about time (the death of Ruby)